When it comes to classic frozen desserts, the Eskimo Pie and the Ice Cream Sandwich are two favorites. But how do they differ in taste, texture, and nutrition? Let’s explore the key differences, calories, pricing, and even the history behind these treats.
What is an Eskimo Pie?
The Eskimo Pie is a chocolate-coated vanilla ice cream bar, first created in 1921. Originally, it had a thin wafer layer, but today, it’s typically sold as a chocolate-covered bar, sometimes on a stick.
Key Features
- Chocolate shell with vanilla ice cream inside
- Creamy, rich texture
- Originally included wafers (modern versions may not)
- Sold as individual wrapped bars
Eskimo Pie Calories
A standard Eskimo Pie bar contains around 150-170 calories, depending on size and ingredients.
What Happened to Eskimo Pie Ice Cream?
The brand faced controversy over its name (now rebranded as “Polar Pie” in some regions) but is still available in many stores under its original name.
What is an Ice Cream Sandwich?
An Ice Cream Sandwich consists of vanilla ice cream pressed between two soft chocolate wafers or cookies. Unlike the Eskimo Pie, it has no chocolate coating—just a chewy, cookie-like exterior.
Key Features
- Soft wafers with creamy ice cream in the middle
- No chocolate shell—just cookie layers
- Easy to eat without melting too quickly
- Often sold in rectangular or round shapes
Also Read this Related Post : Best Homemade Eskimo Pie Popsicle Recipe
Ice Cream Sandwich Price in USA
Prices vary, but a typical ice cream sandwich in the USA costs between $1 to $3, depending on brand and size.
Eskimo Pie vs Ice Cream Sandwich Comparison Table
| Feature | Eskimo Pie | Ice Cream Sandwich |
| Texture | Creamy ice cream with a hard chocolate shell | Soft wafers with smooth ice cream |
| Coating | Chocolate-covered | No coating just wafer layers |
| Shape | Bar or stick | Rectangular or round |
| Calories | 150-170 per bar | 140-180 per sandwich |
| Taste | Rich chocolate + creamy vanilla | Mild sweetness with chewy wafers |
Which One is Better?
- Choose Eskimo Pie if you love chocolate-coated ice cream with a creamy texture.
- Pick an Ice Cream Sandwich if you prefer a softer, cookie-like bite without a hard shell.
FAQ’s
How is Eskimo ice cream different from regular ice cream?
Eskimo Pie is a chocolate-coated bar, while regular ice cream is typically served in a cone or cup.
What’s the original Eskimo Pie vs. Ice Cream Sandwich history?
Eskimo Pie (1921) was one of the first chocolate-covered bars, while ice cream sandwiches date back to the 19th century.
Are both still available in the USA?
Yes! You can find both in most grocery stores and ice cream shops.
1 thought on “Eskimo Pie vs Ice Cream Sandwich – Delicious Comparison”